Commit Graph

726 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
David Goldblatt
2f00ce4da7 Header refactoring: break out ph.h dependencies 2017-04-11 11:52:30 -07:00
David Goldblatt
57e36e1a12 Header refactoring: Add CPP_PROLOGUE and CPP_EPILOGUE macros 2017-04-11 11:52:30 -07:00
Qi Wang
bfa530b75b Pass dealloc_ctx down free() fast path.
This gets rid of the redundent rtree lookup down fast path.
2017-04-11 09:58:12 -07:00
Qi Wang
04ef218d87 Move reentrancy_level to the beginning of TSD. 2017-04-07 16:25:43 -07:00
David Goldblatt
b407a65401 Add basic reentrancy-checking support, and allow arena_new to reenter.
This checks whether or not we're reentrant using thread-local data, and, if we
are, moves certain internal allocations to use arena 0 (which should be properly
initialized after bootstrapping).

The immediate thing this allows is spinning up threads in arena_new, which will
enable spinning up background threads there.
2017-04-07 14:10:27 -07:00
David Goldblatt
0a0fcd3e6a Add hooking functionality
This allows us to hook chosen functions and do interesting things there (in
particular: reentrancy checking).
2017-04-07 14:10:27 -07:00
Qi Wang
36bd90b962 Optimizing TSD and thread cache layout.
1) Re-organize TSD so that frequently accessed fields are closer to the
beginning and more compact.  Assuming 64-bit, the first 2.5 cachelines now
contains everything needed on tcache fast path, expect the tcache struct itself.

2) Re-organize tcache and tbins.  Take lg_fill_div out of tbin, and reduce tbin
to 24 bytes (down from 32). Split tbins into tbins_small and tbins_large, and
place tbins_small close to the beginning.
2017-04-07 14:06:17 -07:00
Qi Wang
0fba57e579 Get rid of tcache_enabled_t as we have runtime init support. 2017-04-07 10:42:29 -07:00
Qi Wang
fde3e20cc0 Integrate auto tcache into TSD.
The embedded tcache is initialized upon tsd initialization.  The avail arrays
for the tbins will be allocated / deallocated accordingly during init / cleanup.

With this change, the pointer to the auto tcache will always be available, as
long as we have access to the TSD.  tcache_available() (called in tcache_get())
is provided to check if we should use tcache.
2017-04-07 09:55:14 -07:00
David Goldblatt
eeabdd2466 Remove the pre-C11-atomics API, which is now unused 2017-04-05 16:25:37 -07:00
David Goldblatt
5dcc13b342 Make the mutex n_waiting_thds field a C11-style atomic 2017-04-05 16:25:37 -07:00
David Goldblatt
30d74db08e Convert accumbytes in prof_accum_t to C11 atomics, when possible 2017-04-05 16:25:37 -07:00
David Goldblatt
92aafb0efe Make base_t's extent_hooks field C11-atomic 2017-04-05 16:25:37 -07:00
David Goldblatt
56b72c7b17 Transition arena struct fields to C11 atomics 2017-04-05 16:25:37 -07:00
David Goldblatt
bc32ec3503 Move arena-tracking atomics in jemalloc.c to C11-style 2017-04-05 16:25:37 -07:00
David Goldblatt
864adb7f42 Transition e_prof_tctx in struct extent to C11 atomics 2017-04-04 16:46:04 -07:00
David Goldblatt
7da04a6b09 Convert prng module to use C11-style atomics 2017-04-04 16:45:52 -07:00
Qi Wang
492e9f301e Make the tsd member init functions to take tsd_t * type. 2017-04-04 14:06:07 -07:00
Qi Wang
d3cda3423c Do proper cleanup for tsd_state_reincarnated.
Also enable arena_bind under non-nominal state, as the cleanup will be handled
correctly now.
2017-04-04 00:34:49 -07:00
Qi Wang
51d3682950 Remove the leafkey NULL check in leaf_elm_lookup. 2017-04-04 00:27:35 -07:00
Qi Wang
9ed84b0d45 Add init function support to tsd members.
This will facilitate embedding tcache into tsd, which will require proper
initialization cannot be done via the static initializer.  Make tsd->rtree_ctx
to be initialized via rtree_ctx_data_init().
2017-04-04 00:19:21 -07:00
Jason Evans
07f4f93434 Move arena_slab_data_t's nfree into extent_t's e_bits.
Compact extent_t to 128 bytes on 64-bit systems by moving
arena_slab_data_t's nfree into extent_t's e_bits.

Cacheline-align extent_t structures so that they always cross the
minimum number of cacheline boundaries.

Re-order extent_t fields such that all fields except the slab bitmap
(and overlaid heap profiling context pointer) are in the first
cacheline.

This resolves #461.
2017-03-27 22:43:39 -07:00
Qi Wang
af3d737a9a Simplify rtree cache replacement policy.
To avoid memmove on free() fast path, simplify the cache replacement policy to
only bubble up the cache hit element by 1.
2017-03-27 13:42:31 -07:00
Jason Evans
c6d1819e48 Simplify rtree_clear() to avoid locking. 2017-03-27 13:22:52 -07:00
Jason Evans
4020523f67 Fix a race in rtree_szind_slab_update() for RTREE_LEAF_COMPACT. 2017-03-27 13:22:36 -07:00
Jason Evans
7c00f04ff4 Remove BITMAP_USE_TREE.
Remove tree-structured bitmap support, in order to reduce complexity and
ease maintenance.  No bitmaps larger than 512 bits have been necessary
since before 4.0.0, and there is no current plan that would increase
maximum bitmap size.  Although tree-structured bitmaps were used on
32-bit platforms prior to this change, the overall benefits were
questionable (higher metadata overhead, higher bitmap modification cost,
marginally lower search cost).
2017-03-27 12:18:40 -07:00
Jason Evans
6258176c87 Fix bitmap_ffu() to work with 3+ levels. 2017-03-27 12:18:40 -07:00
Jason Evans
735ad8210c Pack various extent_t fields into a bitfield.
This reduces sizeof(extent_t) from 160 to 136 on x64.
2017-03-25 23:30:13 -07:00
Jason Evans
0591c204b4 Store arena index rather than (arena_t *) in extent_t. 2017-03-25 23:30:13 -07:00
Jason Evans
5e12223925 Fix BITMAP_USE_TREE version of bitmap_ffu().
This fixes an extent searching regression on 32-bit systems, caused by
the initial bitmap_ffu() implementation in
c8021d01f6 (Implement bitmap_ffu(), which
finds the first unset bit.), as first used in
5d33233a5e (Use a bitmap in extents_t to
speed up search.).
2017-03-25 23:29:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
5d33233a5e Use a bitmap in extents_t to speed up search.
Rather than iteratively checking all sufficiently large heaps during
search, maintain and use a bitmap in order to skip empty heaps.
2017-03-24 17:52:46 -07:00
Jason Evans
57e353163f Implement BITMAP_GROUPS(). 2017-03-24 17:52:46 -07:00
Jason Evans
c8021d01f6 Implement bitmap_ffu(), which finds the first unset bit. 2017-03-24 17:52:46 -07:00
Qi Wang
362e356675 Profile per arena base mutex, instead of just a0. 2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
d3fde1c124 Refactor mutex profiling code with x-macros. 2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
f6698ec1e6 Switch to nstime_t for the time related fields in mutex profiling. 2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
74f78cafda Added custom mutex spin.
A fixed max spin count is used -- with benchmark results showing it
solves almost all problems. As the benchmark used was rather intense,
the upper bound could be a little bit high. However it should offer a
good tradeoff between spinning and blocking.
2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
20b8c70e9f Added extents_dirty / _muzzy mutexes, as well as decay_dirty / _muzzy. 2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
64c5f5c174 Added "stats.mutexes.reset" mallctl to reset all mutex stats.
Also switched from the term "lock" to "mutex".
2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
ca9074deff Added lock profiling and output for global locks (ctl, prof and base). 2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
0fb5c0e853 Add arena lock stats output. 2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
a4f176af57 Output bin lock profiling results to malloc_stats.
Two counters are included for the small bins: lock contention rate, and
max lock waiting time.
2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Qi Wang
6309df628f First stage of mutex profiling.
Switched to trylock and update counters based on state.
2017-03-23 00:03:28 -07:00
Jason Evans
32e7cf51cd Further specialize arena_[s]dalloc() tcache fast path.
Use tsd_rtree_ctx() rather than tsdn_rtree_ctx() when tcache is
non-NULL, in order to avoid an extra branch (and potentially extra stack
space) in the fast path.
2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
5e67fbc367 Push down iealloc() calls.
Call iealloc() as deep into call chains as possible without causing
redundant calls.
2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
51a2ec92a1 Remove extent dereferences from the deallocation fast paths. 2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
4f341412e5 Remove extent arg from isalloc() and arena_salloc(). 2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
0ee0e0c155 Implement compact rtree leaf element representation.
If a single virtual adddress pointer has enough unused bits to pack
{szind_t, extent_t *, bool, bool}, use a single pointer-sized field in
each rtree leaf element, rather than using three separate fields.  This
has little impact on access speed (fewer loads/stores, but more bit
twiddling), except that denser representation increases TLB
effectiveness.
2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
ce41ab0c57 Embed root node into rtree_t.
This avoids one atomic operation per tree access.
2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
99d68445ef Incorporate szind/slab into rtree leaves.
Expand and restructure the rtree API such that all common operations can
be achieved with minimal work, regardless of whether the rtree leaf
fields are independent versus packed into a single atomic pointer.
2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
944c8a3383 Split rtree_elm_t into rtree_{node,leaf}_elm_t.
This allows leaf elements to differ in size from internal node elements.

In principle it would be more correct to use a different type for each
level of the tree, but due to implementation details related to atomic
operations, we use casts anyway, thus counteracting the value of
additional type correctness.  Furthermore, such a scheme would require
function code generation (via cpp macros), as well as either unwieldy
type names for leaves or type aliases, e.g.

  typedef struct rtree_elm_d2_s rtree_leaf_elm_t;

This alternate strategy would be more correct, and with less code
duplication, but probably not worth the complexity.
2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
f50d6009fe Remove binind field from arena_slab_data_t.
binind is now redundant; the containing extent_t's szind field always
provides the same value.
2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
e8921cf2eb Convert extent_t's usize to szind.
Rather than storing usize only for large (and prof-promoted)
allocations, store the size class index for allocations that reside
within the extent, such that the size class index is valid for all
extents that contain extant allocations, and invalid otherwise (mainly
to make debugging simpler).
2017-03-22 18:33:32 -07:00
Jason Evans
64e458f5cd Implement two-phase decay-based purging.
Split decay-based purging into two phases, the first of which uses lazy
purging to convert dirty pages to "muzzy", and the second of which uses
forced purging, decommit, or unmapping to convert pages to clean or
destroy them altogether.  Not all operating systems support lazy
purging, yet the application may provide extent hooks that implement
lazy purging, so care must be taken to dynamically omit the first phase
when necessary.

The mallctl interfaces change as follows:
- opt.decay_time --> opt.{dirty,muzzy}_decay_time
- arena.<i>.decay_time --> arena.<i>.{dirty,muzzy}_decay_time
- arenas.decay_time --> arenas.{dirty,muzzy}_decay_time
- stats.arenas.<i>.pdirty --> stats.arenas.<i>.p{dirty,muzzy}
- stats.arenas.<i>.{npurge,nmadvise,purged} -->
  stats.arenas.<i>.{dirty,muzzy}_{npurge,nmadvise,purged}

This resolves #521.
2017-03-15 13:13:47 -07:00
Jason Evans
38a5bfc816 Move arena_t's purging field into arena_decay_t. 2017-03-15 13:13:47 -07:00
Jason Evans
765edd67b4 Refactor decay-related function parametrization.
Refactor most of the decay-related functions to take as parameters the
decay_t and associated extents_t structures to operate on.  This
prepares for supporting both lazy and forced purging on different decay
schedules.
2017-03-15 13:13:47 -07:00
David Goldblatt
ee202efc79 Convert remaining arena_stats_t fields to atomics
These were all size_ts, so we have atomics support for them on all platforms, so
the conversion is straightforward.

Left non-atomic is curlextents, which AFAICT is not used atomically anywhere.
2017-03-13 18:22:33 -07:00
David Goldblatt
4fc2acf5ae Switch atomic uint64_ts in arena_stats_t to C11 atomics
I expect this to be the trickiest conversion we will see, since we want atomics
on 64-bit platforms, but are also always able to piggyback on some sort of
external synchronization on non-64 bit platforms.
2017-03-13 18:22:33 -07:00
Jason Evans
7cbcd2e2b7 Fix pages_purge_forced() to discard pages on non-Linux systems.
madvise(..., MADV_DONTNEED) only causes demand-zeroing on Linux, so fall
back to overlaying a new mapping.
2017-03-13 18:19:57 -07:00
David Goldblatt
21a68e2d22 Convert rtree code to use C11 atomics
In the process, I changed the implementation of rtree_elm_acquire so that it
won't even try to CAS if its initial read (getting the extent + lock bit)
indicates that the CAS is doomed to fail.  This can significantly improve
performance under contention.
2017-03-13 12:05:27 -07:00
Jason Evans
3a2b183d5f Convert arena_t's purging field to non-atomic bool.
The decay mutex already protects all accesses.
2017-03-10 10:14:30 -08:00
Jason Evans
75fddc786c Fix ATOMIC_{ACQUIRE,RELEASE,ACQ_REL} definitions. 2017-03-09 00:57:37 -08:00
Qi Wang
ec532e2c5c Implement per-CPU arena.
The new feature, opt.percpu_arena, determines thread-arena association
dynamically based CPU id. Three modes are supported: "percpu", "phycpu"
and disabled.

"percpu" uses the current core id (with help from sched_getcpu())
directly as the arena index, while "phycpu" will assign threads on the
same physical CPU to the same arena. In other words, "percpu" means # of
arenas == # of CPUs, while "phycpu" has # of arenas == 1/2 * (# of
CPUs). Note that no runtime check on whether hyper threading is enabled
is added yet.

When enabled, threads will be migrated between arenas when a CPU change
is detected. In the current design, to reduce overhead from reading CPU
id, each arena tracks the thread accessed most recently. When a new
thread comes in, we will read CPU id and update arena if necessary.
2017-03-08 23:19:01 -08:00
Qi Wang
8721e19c04 Fix arena_prefork lock rank order for witness.
When witness is enabled, lock rank order needs to be preserved during
prefork, not only for each arena, but also across arenas. This change
breaks arena_prefork into further stages to ensure valid rank order
across arenas. Also changed test/unit/fork to use a manual arena to
catch this case.
2017-03-08 23:07:27 -08:00
David Goldblatt
8adab26972 Convert extents_t's npages field to use C11-style atomics
In the process, we can do some strength reduction, changing the fetch-adds and
fetch-subs to be simple loads followed by stores, since the modifications all
occur while holding the mutex.
2017-03-08 21:27:09 -08:00
David Goldblatt
dafadce622 Reintroduce JEMALLOC_ATOMIC_U64
The C11 atomics backport removed this #define, which degraded atomic 64-bit
reads to require a lock even on platforms that support them.  This commit fixes
that.
2017-03-08 21:26:37 -08:00
Qi Wang
01f47f11a6 Store associated arena in tcache.
This fixes tcache_flush for manual tcaches, which wasn't able to find
the correct arena it associated with. Also changed the decay test to
cover this case (by using manually created arenas).
2017-03-07 12:58:11 -08:00
Jason Evans
cc75c35db5 Add any() and remove_any() to ph.
These functions select the easiest-to-remove element in the heap, which
is either the most recently inserted aux list element or the root.  If
no calls are made to first() or remove_first(), the behavior (and time
complexity) is the same as for a LIFO queue.
2017-03-07 10:25:33 -08:00
Jason Evans
e201e24904 Perform delayed coalescing prior to purging.
Rather than purging uncoalesced extents, perform just enough incremental
coalescing to purge only fully coalesced extents.  In the absence of
cached extent reuse, the immediate versus delayed incremental purging
algorithms result in the same purge order.

This resolves #655.
2017-03-07 10:25:12 -08:00
David Goldblatt
4f1e94658a Change arena to use the atomic functions for ssize_t instead of the union strategy 2017-03-06 18:49:19 -08:00
David Goldblatt
438efede78 Add atomic types for ssize_t 2017-03-06 18:49:19 -08:00
David Goldblatt
424e3428b1 Make type abbreviations consistent: ssize_t is zd everywhere 2017-03-06 18:49:19 -08:00
David Goldblatt
84326c566a Insert not_reached after an exhaustive switch
In the C11 atomics backport, we couldn't use not_reached() in
atomic_enum_to_builtin (in atomic_gcc_atomic.h), since atomic.h was hermetic and
assert.h wasn't; there was a dependency issue.  assert.h is hermetic now, so we
can include it.
2017-03-06 15:08:43 -08:00
David Goldblatt
e9852b5776 Disentangle assert and util
This is the first header refactoring diff, #533.  It splits the assert and util
components into separate, hermetic, header files.  In the process, it splits out
two of the large sub-components of util (the stdio.h replacement, and bit
manipulation routines) into their own components (malloc_io.h and bit_util.h).
This is mostly to break up cyclic dependencies, but it also breaks off a good
chunk of the catch-all-ness of util, which is nice.
2017-03-06 15:08:43 -08:00
Jason Evans
04d8fcb745 Optimize malloc_large_stats_t maintenance.
Convert the nrequests field to be partially derived, and the curlextents
to be fully derived, in order to reduce the number of stats updates
needed during common operations.

This change affects ndalloc stats during arena reset, because it is no
longer possible to cancel out ndalloc effects (curlextents would become
negative).
2017-03-04 08:18:31 -08:00
David Goldblatt
d4ac7582f3 Introduce a backport of C11 atomics
This introduces a backport of C11 atomics.  It has four implementations; ranked
in order of preference, they are:
- GCC/Clang __atomic builtins
- GCC/Clang __sync builtins
- MSVC _Interlocked builtins
- C11 atomics, from <stdatomic.h>

The primary advantages are:
- Close adherence to the standard API gives us a defined memory model.
- Type safety: atomic objects are now separate types from non-atomic ones, so
  that it's impossible to mix up atomic and non-atomic updates (which is
  undefined behavior that compilers are starting to take advantage of).
- Efficiency: we can specify ordering for operations, avoiding fences and
  atomic operations on strongly ordered architectures (example:
  `atomic_write_u32(ptr, val);` involves a CAS loop, whereas
  `atomic_store(ptr, val, ATOMIC_RELEASE);` is a plain store.

This diff leaves in the current atomics API (implementing them in terms of the
backport).  This lets us transition uses over piecemeal.

Testing:
This is by nature hard to test. I've manually tested the first three options on
Linux on gcc by futzing with the #defines manually, on freebsd with gcc and
clang, on MSVC, and on OS X with clang.  All of these were x86 machines though,
and we don't have any test infrastructure set up for non-x86 platforms.
2017-03-03 13:40:59 -08:00
David Goldblatt
957b8c5f21 Stop #define-ining away 'inline'
In the long term, we'll transition to C99-style inline semantics.  In the
short-term, this will allow both styles to coexist without breaking one another.
2017-03-03 13:40:59 -08:00
Jason Evans
fd058f572b Immediately purge cached extents if decay_time is 0.
This fixes a regression caused by
54269dc0ed (Remove obsolete
arena_maybe_purge() call.), as well as providing a general fix.

This resolves #665.
2017-03-02 19:43:06 -08:00
Jason Evans
d61a5f76b2 Convert arena_decay_t's time to be atomically synchronized. 2017-03-02 19:43:06 -08:00
Jason Evans
472fef2e12 Fix {allocated,nmalloc,ndalloc,nrequests}_large stats regression.
This fixes a regression introduced by
d433471f58 (Derive
{allocated,nmalloc,ndalloc,nrequests}_large stats.).
2017-02-27 11:18:07 -08:00
Jason Evans
079b8bee37 Tidy up extent quantization.
Remove obsolete unit test scaffolding for extent quantization.  Remove
redundant assertions.  Add an assertion to
extents_first_best_fit_locked() that should help prevent aligned
allocation regressions.
2017-02-27 11:17:47 -08:00
Jason Evans
d727596bcb Update a comment. 2017-02-26 11:05:27 -08:00
Qi Wang
c2323e13a5 Get rid of witness in malloc_mutex_t when !(configured w/ debug).
We don't touch witness at all when config_debug == false.  Let's only pay the
memory cost in malloc_mutex_s when needed. Note that when !config_debug, we keep
the field in a union so that we don't have to do #ifdefs in multiple places.
2017-02-24 09:41:29 -08:00
Jason Evans
8ac7937eb5 Remove remainder of mb (memory barrier).
This complements 94c5d22a4d (Remove mb.h,
which is unused).
2017-02-22 00:24:14 -08:00
Jason Evans
003ca8717f Move arena_basic_stats_merge() prototype (hygienic cleanup). 2017-02-21 12:46:20 -08:00
Jason Evans
2dfc5b5aac Disable coalescing of cached extents.
Extent splitting and coalescing is a major component of large allocation
overhead, and disabling coalescing of cached extents provides a simple
and effective hysteresis mechanism.  Once two-phase purging is
implemented, it will probably make sense to leave coalescing disabled
for the first phase, but coalesce during the second phase.
2017-02-16 20:11:50 -08:00
Jason Evans
b0654b95ed Fix arena->stats.mapped accounting.
Mapped memory increases when extent_alloc_wrapper() succeeds, and
decreases when extent_dalloc_wrapper() is called (during purging).
2017-02-16 15:52:11 -08:00
Jason Evans
f8fee6908d Synchronize arena->decay with arena->decay.mtx.
This removes the last use of arena->lock.
2017-02-16 09:39:46 -08:00
Jason Evans
d433471f58 Derive {allocated,nmalloc,ndalloc,nrequests}_large stats.
This mildly reduces stats update overhead during normal operation.
2017-02-16 09:39:46 -08:00
Jason Evans
ab25d3c987 Synchronize arena->tcache_ql with arena->tcache_ql_mtx.
This replaces arena->lock synchronization.
2017-02-16 09:39:46 -08:00
Jason Evans
6b5cba4191 Convert arena->stats synchronization to atomics. 2017-02-16 09:39:46 -08:00
Jason Evans
fa2d64c94b Convert arena->prof_accumbytes synchronization to atomics. 2017-02-16 09:39:46 -08:00
Jason Evans
b779522b9b Convert arena->dss_prec synchronization to atomics. 2017-02-16 09:39:46 -08:00
Jason Evans
0721b895ff Do not generate unused tsd_*_[gs]et() functions.
This avoids a gcc diagnostic note:
    note: The ABI for passing parameters with 64-byte alignment has
    changed in GCC 4.6
This note related to the cacheline alignment of rtree_ctx_t, which was
introduced by 4a346f5593 (Replace rtree
path cache with LRU cache.).
2017-02-13 10:47:16 -08:00
Jason Evans
6b8ef771a9 Fix rtree_subkey() regression.
Fix rtree_subkey() to use uintptr_t rather than unsigned for key
bitmasking.  This regression was introduced by
4a346f5593 (Replace rtree path cache with
LRU cache.).
2017-02-10 09:05:02 -08:00
Jason Evans
7f55dbef9b Enable mutex witnesses even when !isthreaded.
This fixes interactions with witness_assert_depth[_to_rank](), which was
added in d0e93ada51 (Add
witness_assert_depth[_to_rank]().).
2017-02-09 17:05:47 -08:00
Jason Evans
db7da56359 Spin adaptively in rtree_elm_acquire(). 2017-02-08 18:50:03 -08:00
Jason Evans
de8a68e853 Enhance spin_adaptive() to yield after several iterations.
This avoids worst case behavior if e.g. another thread is preempted
while owning the resource the spinning thread is waiting for.
2017-02-08 18:50:03 -08:00
Jason Evans
5f11830754 Replace spin_init() with SPIN_INITIALIZER. 2017-02-08 18:50:03 -08:00
Jason Evans
650c070e10 Remove rtree support for 0 (NULL) keys.
NULL can never actually be inserted in practice, and removing support
allows a branch to be removed from the fast path.
2017-02-08 18:50:03 -08:00